I made an apple pie yesterday. I rolled out my first pie crust in 4 years. And making crust is stressful. there are millions of recipes and like with most 'commodity' recipes, i look to
Cooks' Illustrated. I won't print an apple pie recipe since those are also easily found.
They had a couple great tips:
- it's better to have a slightly tacky (or wet) dough since you can add flour
- use a tapered rolling pin with a clockwise rotation
- chill rolled out bottom crust while rolling out the top crust
Here are my great tips
- use about 3/4 the apples any recipe calls for - it's always too much
- use a lot of "table" flour to keep your dough from sticking
- replace water with apple juice concentrate (learned this from someone talking about Alton Brown)
- allow your pie to cool for 6 hours!
I chose the apples I like the best:
- 1 1/2 pounds Honeycrisp
- 1/2 pound Pink Lady
- 1/2 pound Mutsu
After eating a slice, my wife (also my harshest critic) found me cleaning the bathroom and said, "That is the best pie I've ever eaten. Any pie. Anywhere."
So far - APAW is a success. Next MEYER LEMON TART. Hopefully less stress.